NACSA responds to the Center for Media and Democracy’s Report “Charter School Black Hole”

Stay Updated With The Latest News

NACSA is committed to sharing regular updates on the latest federal COVID-19 information available in an effort to highlight education policies taking place during the pandemic. Primarily, these updates will focus on the latest packages Congress is considering and guidance from the U.S. Department of Education.

NACSA responds to the Center for Media and Democracy’s Report “Charter School Black Hole”

The National Association of Charter School Authorizers (NACSA) is a non-profit, professional organization that has worked with states, school districts and other authorizers to strengthen charter school oversight across the country for the past 15 years. We provide authorizers with tools and resources to make sure charters are transparent and accountable to our nation’s taxpayers.

The Center for Media and Democracy’s report legitimately highlights some troubling problems in Ohio. Most of the report’s criticisms are aimed at the U.S. Department of Education and its administration of the federal Charter School Program grant fund. We are disappointed the report purposely omits any reference to the significant improvements that have occurred in Ohio over the past years.

NACSA has pushed for accountability and transparency in Ohio for more than 10 years. In 2006, we issued a tough report on the state’s charter sector—together with the Thomas B. Fordham Institute and the National Alliance for Public Charter Schools—calling for significant changes to state law. We advocated for a way to automatically close the worst performing schools and a process to evaluate authorizers based on school performance. With our support, these two measures became law in 2010. We supported the strong charter school reform bill passed this month, which creates additional charter school oversight and transparency provisions.

Because of this hard work, Ohio now has one of the strongest charter school accountability laws in the nation. NACSA readily endorsed Ohio’s application to the federal Charter School Program for additional funds based on this progress.

However, a law is only as good as its implementation, which the state saw this summer with the flawed administration of the new authorizer evaluation process. NACSA offered to work with the Ohio Department of Education to make sure the state’s charter reform laws are faithfully implemented at all levels.

At the end of the day, quality authorizing is the key to sustainable, high-performing charter sector.

We will continue to push Ohio’s authorizers to set and maintain high expectations for schools. This means taking action to close the charter schools that are failing children. It means adopting professional authorizing standards that create a strong review process that allows only the schools with the most likelihood of succeeding to open.

We will continue to push for Ohio’s authorizers to be held accountable for their own performance as well. There must be consequences for authorizers that continually approve schools that never open, schools that close within months of opening, and schools that drastically fail children year after year.

The work of NACSA and its partners will continue to create real and sustained progress to create schools that fit the needs for every Buckeye child.


The National Association of Charter School Authorizers (NACSA) is an independent voice for effective charter school policy and thoughtful charter authorizing practices that lead to more great public schools. Our research, policy, and consultation work advances excellence and accountability in the charter school sector. With authorizers and other partners, we have built the gold standard for charter school authorizing. Through smart charter school growth, these authorizers will give hundreds of thousands of children an opportunity for a better education each year. More at


Most Recent Posts
Holding Up a Mirror: What to Expect at 2021 NACSA Virtual Leadership Conference for Charter School Authorizers
As educators, we need to recognize the significance of this moment for charter school authorizers. The pandemic has interrupted schooling for millions of children–widening achievement and opportunity gaps that we...
Wyoming Gets a New Authorizer Is the Headline, But There’s More to the Story
Last month we touched on a Wyoming bill, SF130, which created a new authorizing pathway in the state. But there is more to the bill that deserves to be highlighted: through a comprehensive overhaul, SF130...
Amid Change, Our Autonomy and Community Are Our Strength
This blog post was written by Dr. Sana Shaikh, who served until this spring as Director of School Operations at Rise Prep High School, an autonomous school in Springfield, Massachusetts. Rise...